6 min readBy Michael Newborn

Ask for the Why: What to Do After Being Told No

I talked with Giovanna Camacho, who goes by G, about the times people told her no.

West Point took her at 17, and she left the Army at 29. After that she started a PhD program in systems engineering at the University of Virginia. She now works at NASA Armstrong.

For her PhD she began work on a wearable that sends touch cues. It is meant to help a diver, an astronaut or someone who is visually impaired stay oriented.

When she applied to West Point, her high school counselor said a 4.2 from Dixon High "doesn't mean a whole lot." She pointed G toward community college. G got her signature on the paperwork at lunch, and she was accepted.

Later, an advisor refused to write her a letter for UVA, her first-choice doctoral program. The reason was that G hadn't applied to the school the advisor preferred. Her boss pointed out that she could ask almost anyone on the faculty. Albert Bouquet, who taught her statistics, said he'd write it in the next 30 minutes. He did.

Her rule: "I want to be told no, and I want to be told no and why." She accepts a reason that holds up. "If it's a no and a why that is realistic, then I can stomach that."

Rules that keep people out

G volunteered with Force Blue, a diving nonprofit. Applicants needed front-line combat time, and women of her generation weren't allowed in combat then. She raised it, and they fixed it. More women signed up after that.

She told me, "People just don't know sometimes when they put out these requirements."

Why the reason matters

Each of those nos came with a reason G could check, and many job seekers today don't get one. The hiring platform Greenhouse surveyed 1,200 U.S. job seekers for a report released October 20, 2026. Of those, 81 percent said a company had rejected them in the past year before anyone there spoke with them.

I wanted to know whether getting a reason changes what people do next. Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach looked at what people learn from failure, in research published in Psychological Science in 2019. Across five studies with 1,674 people, participants learned less from being told they got something wrong than from being told they got it right. The authors traced it to ego. A personal failure made people tune out.

Sebahat Gok and Emily Fyfe ran six experiments with 1,306 people for a 2024 study in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. They found the same drop in learning after failure. The drop went away when a short explanation of how to get it right came right after the failure. In some cases people learned more after failing than after succeeding.

Why people stop asking

G waited a year on a scholarship because one person told her she wasn't ready. The next year, that person asked what she was waiting for. She applied and won it. The money paid for her first prototype.

In a 2022 study in Psychological Science, Xuan Zhao and Nicholas Epley looked at how people judge a request for help before they make it. They tested 2,118 U.S. adults in scenarios and live conversations. The people who needed help underestimated how willing others were to give it. They also expected helpers to feel more put out than the helpers said they felt.

What to do

  1. Before you ask, decide your minimum and who you'll try next. Keep that minimum through a bad week.
  2. When you hear no on something that matters, ask for the reason and write it down.
  3. When the reason points at your work, fix it. If the no came from a rule, from what the other person didn't know, or with no reason at all, take the same ask to someone else.

Questions people ask

What should I do after being told no?

Ask why. Then either fix what the reason points to or go to the next person on your list. Giovanna Camacho's rule is "I want to be told no, and I want to be told no and why."

How do I handle rejection when I'm starting something new?

Ask each person who says no for their reason, and have the next person picked out before you ask. Giovanna Camacho once held off on a scholarship for a year after hearing she wasn't ready, then won it when she applied.

Do people say yes more often than we expect?

Usually more than the person asking predicts. Zhao and Epley's 2022 study of 2,118 U.S. adults in Psychological Science found that people seeking help underestimated how willing others were and how good helpers would feel about it.

Does knowing why you were rejected help?

Yes. Knowing the reason makes it easier to learn from a no. Research from the University of Chicago, published in Psychological Science in 2019, found that people take in less from a failure than from a success. A failure that feels personal makes people stop paying attention. A 2024 study in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General found that when a short explanation came with the failure, people learned from it as well as from a success, and sometimes better. If someone tells you no without a reason, ask for one.

Should I lower my expectations after a few rejections?

A 2026 Journal of Applied Psychology study of job seekers found that those who kept their minimum salary goal higher through the search received higher offers.

Who is Giovanna Camacho?

A former Army officer and West Point graduate who now works at NASA Armstrong. She began a PhD in systems engineering at UVA, where she worked on a touch-based wearable for orientation underwater, in space and for people with low vision.

In short

Giovanna Camacho, a West Point graduate who works at NASA Armstrong, asks for the reason behind every no she hears: "I want to be told no, and I want to be told no and why." She accepts a no when the reason holds up and asks someone else when it does not. Her approach to what to do after being told no: ask for the reason, fix the work if the reason is about the work, and otherwise take the same ask to someone else. In a 2019 Psychological Science study of 1,674 people, Lauren Eskreis-Winkler and Ayelet Fishbach found people learn less from failure feedback than from success feedback. In a 2024 Journal of Experimental Psychology: General study, Sebahat Gok and Emily Fyfe replicated that result in six preregistered experiments with 1,306 people and found it disappeared when a short explanation followed the failure. In a 2022 Psychological Science study of 2,118 U.S. adults, Xuan Zhao and Nicholas Epley found people seeking help underestimated how willing others were to help. Greenhouse's 2026 Future of Hiring Candidate Report, released October 20, 2026, found 81 percent of 1,200 U.S. job seekers had at least one rejection in the past year with no contact from anyone at the company.

For more perspective on this topic, listen to Strength Through Struggle with Giovanna Camacho (Discover How Giovanna’s Journey from Foster Care to NASA Teaches Resilience, Reinvention, and Finding Your True Path).

Share

Need clarity? Start a private chat to find your direction, then discover the right person to help you get there.